This is an old revision of the document!


The Area Chair process

  • By January 23, I will have assigned papers to each of you.
  • By January 30, please assign papers to reviewers. Each paper will be assigned to 2 ACs. You can see all the reviewers. Each of you should assign 2 reviewers to each paper.

Assigning papers to reviewers

  • One key issue: you are asking Area Chairs to assign papers to the reviewers that they themselves recruited. If you feel that you have a paper that really should be assigned to a reviewer that you did not recruit, please send me email first, and I will let the recruiting area chair know. Since everyone did a great job of recruiting reviewers, this should not be a problem. Also, if you want to recruit additional reviewers once you see the papers, this should be no problem.
  • A second key issue: remember not to give review assignments to other Area Chairs. This will not work out well for you.
  • I recommend you download your papers first. It may be easiest to work through the papers offline, assigning reviewers to papers, and then entering the information into CMT afterwards.
  • The easiest way to assign reviewers seems to be as a two-step process. First, give yourself some suggested reviewers using the “Manage Reviewer Candidate Suggestions” link. The reason for this is that you get to see the reviewer keywords easily.
  • Once you've given yourself a set of candidate reviewers for each paper, go back to the main screen (probably easiest to click on “Select your role: Meta-Reviewer” and click “Manage Assignments, Bids and Conflicts”
  • Alongside each paper it will say on the far right, “Edit Bids / Edit Conflicts / Edit Assignments”.
  • Clicking on “Edit Assignments” will bring up a list of your suggested reviewers. You finish the assignment by clicking the box along the right-hand side and then clicking “Save”. REMEMBER TO CLICK SAVE otherwise you will lose your assignments.
ac_instructions.1291867949.txt.gz · Last modified: 2011/02/26 14:54 (external edit)